DATAPITCH
← Props Picker, this week's games
at

Indianapolis Colts at Washington Commanders

Week 4 · Sun Oct 4, 9:30 AM ET · Market line WAS +3.5 · total 47.5

Our read on this game

Nothing on this game clears our bar tonight. Every market we price is below anyway, each row with the market's own price and what our read rests on.

Strongest of themJosh DownsWR · IND1+ rushing yards+500consensus market price

Prices taken Wed 30 Sept, 14:12 UK. 1 row on this game carries a doubtful man, marked on the row and with the reason behind its tap.

Every market we price

20 rows on 4 markets, best first: tap a market to open it, tap a player for his numbers, the price behind his and what our read rests on.

Receiving yards6
Jonathan Taylor RB · IND 20+ receiving yards-114consensus market price

Jonathan TaylorRB · INDReceiving yards

DataPitch 48% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -5pp

Under 19.5: -114consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receiving yards
average 23.8, median 19
The line
19.5

His last 5, receiving yards

4v HOU2026 week 3
40v KC2026 week 2
23v BAL2026 week 1
13v HOU2025 week 18
14v JAX2025 week 17
Keenan Allen WR · IND 35+ receiving yards-115consensus market price

Keenan AllenWR · INDReceiving yards

DataPitch 48% · Market 54%

Against this price: Gap -6pp

Under 34.5: -113consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receiving yards
average 38.1, median 33
The line
34.5

His last 5, receiving yards

63v HOU2026 week 3
5v KC2026 week 2
32v BAL2026 week 1
25v NE2025 week 19
36v DEN2025 week 18
More players (4)
Tyler Warren TE · IND 47+ receiving yards-114consensus market price

Tyler WarrenTE · INDReceiving yards

DataPitch 38% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -15pp

Under 46.5: -114consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receiving yards
average 43.3, median 37
The line
46.5

His last 5, receiving yards

55v HOU2026 week 3
21v KC2026 week 2
13v BAL2026 week 1
26v HOU2025 week 18
43v JAX2025 week 17
Stefon Diggs WR · WAS 42+ receiving yards-114consensus market price

Stefon DiggsWR · WASReceiving yards

DataPitch 34% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -19pp

Under 41.5: -113consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receiving yards
average 35.5, median 30
The line
41.5

His last 5, receiving yards

33v SEA2026 week 3
47v DAL2026 week 2
55v PHI2026 week 1
37v SEA2025 week 22
17v DEN2025 week 21
Terry McLaurin WR · WAS 56+ receiving yards-114consensus market price

Terry McLaurinWR · WASReceiving yards

DataPitch 23% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -30pp

Under 55.5: -114consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receiving yards
average 37.3, median 32
The line
55.5

His last 5, receiving yards

77v SEA2026 week 3
50v DAL2026 week 2
14v PHI2026 week 1
57v PHI2025 week 18
63v DAL2025 week 17
Josh Downs WR · IND 64+ receiving yards-117consensus market price

Josh DownsWR · INDReceiving yards

DataPitch 15% · Market 54%

Against this price: Gap -39pp

Under 63.5: -113consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receiving yards
average 36.3, median 31
The line
63.5

His last 5, receiving yards

77v HOU2026 week 3
72v KC2026 week 2
37v BAL2026 week 1
61v HOU2025 week 18
34v JAX2025 week 17
Receptions6
Jonathan Taylor RB · IND 3+ receptions-130consensus market price

Jonathan TaylorRB · INDReceptions

DataPitch 47% · Market 57%

Against this price: Gap -10pp

Under 2.5: +100consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receptions
average 2.7, median 2
The line
2.5

His last 5, receptions

2v HOU2026 week 3
4v KC2026 week 2
3v BAL2026 week 1
2v HOU2025 week 18
3v JAX2025 week 17
Keenan Allen WR · IND 4+ receptions-120consensus market price

Keenan AllenWR · INDReceptions

DataPitch 39% · Market 55%

Against this price: Gap -16pp

Under 3.5: -104consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receptions
average 3.2, median 3
The line
3.5

His last 5, receptions

6v HOU2026 week 3
1v KC2026 week 2
6v BAL2026 week 1
3v NE2025 week 19
7v DEN2025 week 18
More players (4)
Josh Downs WR · IND 6+ receptions+120consensus market price

Josh DownsWR · INDReceptions

DataPitch 18% · Market 46%

Against this price: Gap -28pp

Under 5.5: -159consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receptions
average 3.6, median 3
The line
5.5

His last 5, receptions

5v HOU2026 week 3
7v KC2026 week 2
2v BAL2026 week 1
4v HOU2025 week 18
2v JAX2025 week 17
Tyler Warren TE · IND 6+ receptions-101consensus market price

Tyler WarrenTE · INDReceptions

DataPitch 23% · Market 50%

Against this price: Gap -27pp

Under 5.5: -130consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receptions
average 3.9, median 4
The line
5.5

His last 5, receptions

9v HOU2026 week 3
6v KC2026 week 2
3v BAL2026 week 1
5v HOU2025 week 18
5v JAX2025 week 17
Stefon Diggs WR · WAS 5+ receptions+120consensus market price

Stefon DiggsWR · WASReceptions

DataPitch 17% · Market 46%

Against this price: Gap -29pp

Under 4.5: -155consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receptions
average 2.7, median 2
The line
4.5

His last 5, receptions

4v SEA2026 week 3
5v DAL2026 week 2
4v PHI2026 week 1
3v SEA2025 week 22
5v DEN2025 week 21
Terry McLaurin WR · WAS 5+ receptions-111consensus market price

Terry McLaurinWR · WASReceptions

DataPitch 16% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -37pp

Under 4.5: -115consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receptions
average 2.7, median 2
The line
4.5

His last 5, receptions

6v SEA2026 week 3
2v DAL2026 week 2
2v PHI2026 week 1
4v PHI2025 week 18
5v DAL2025 week 17
Rushing yards5
Josh Downs WR · IND 1+ rushing yards+500consensus market price

Josh DownsWR · INDRushing yards

DataPitch 17% · Market 17%

Against this price: Gap +0pp

Under 0.5: -833consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated rushing yards
average 2.2, median 0
The line
0.5

His last 5, rushing yards

0v HOU2026 week 3
0v KC2026 week 2
0v BAL2026 week 1
-5v HOU2025 week 18
0v JAX2025 week 17
Jonathan Taylor RB · IND 91+ rushing yards-115consensus market price

Jonathan TaylorRB · INDRushing yards

DataPitch 49% · Market 54%

Against this price: Gap -5pp

Under 90.5: -114consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated rushing yards
average 94.8, median 89
The line
90.5

His last 5, rushing yards

68v HOU2026 week 3
92v KC2026 week 2
98v BAL2026 week 1
26v HOU2025 week 18
70v JAX2025 week 17
More players (3)
Daniel Jones QB · IND 12+ rushing yards-114consensus market price

Daniel JonesQB · INDRushing yards

DataPitch 38% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -15pp

Under 11.5: -114consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated rushing yards
average 13.8, median 7
The line
11.5

His last 5, rushing yards

5v HOU2026 week 3
10v KC2026 week 2
4v BAL2026 week 1
4v JAX2025 week 14
1v HOU2025 week 13
Marcus Mariota QB · WAS 28+ rushing yards-114consensus market price

Marcus MariotaQB · WASRushing yards

DataPitch 21% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -32pp

Under 27.5: -114consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated rushing yards
average 16.1, median 9
The line
27.5

His last 5, rushing yards

11v SEA2026 week 3
3v DAL2026 week 2
-1v PHI2025 week 16
43v NYG2025 week 15
7v MIN2025 week 14
Jacory Croskey-Merritt RB · WAS 56+ rushing yards-113consensus market price

Jacory Croskey-MerrittRB · WASRushing yards

DataPitch 18% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -35pp

Under 55.5: -115consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated rushing yards
average 31.5, median 24
The line
55.5

His last 5, rushing yards

36v SEA2026 week 3
43v DAL2026 week 2
63v PHI2026 week 1
29v PHI2025 week 18
105v DAL2025 week 17
Passing yards3
Marcus Mariota QB · WAS 213+ passing yards-114consensus market price

Marcus MariotaQB · WASPassing yards

DataPitch 48% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -5pp

Under 212.5: -113consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated passing yards
average 213.7, median 209
The line
212.5

His last 5, passing yards

176v SEA2026 week 3
111v DAL2026 week 2
93v PHI2025 week 16
195v NYG2025 week 15
22v MIN2025 week 14
Daniel Jones QB · IND 225+ passing yards-114consensus market price

Daniel JonesQB · INDPassing yards

DataPitch 40% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -13pp

Under 224.5: -114consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated passing yards
average 213.3, median 208
The line
224.5

His last 5, passing yards

211v HOU2026 week 3
210v KC2026 week 2
149v BAL2026 week 1
60v JAX2025 week 14
195v HOU2025 week 13
More players (1)
DoubtfulJayden Daniels QB · WAS 218+ passing yardsno fresh market price in the 2026-09-30 capture; an older price is not shown

Jayden DanielsQB · WASPassing yards

Doubtful: Questionable: Elbow - Questionable for Week 4 vs. Indianapolis

DataPitch 22%

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated passing yards
average 173.8, median 168
The line
217.5

His last 5, passing yards

96v DAL2026 week 2
163v PHI2026 week 1
77v MIN2025 week 14
133v SEA2025 week 9
151v DAL2025 week 7

Every price is a captured market quote in American odds, labelled as such; our percentage and the gap to the market's sit behind the row's tap. A row's colour is the gap against our own publication bar: green clears it, red is negative, white neutral. A row's last five counts his last five games in this market, most recent first, regular season and playoffs.

Around this game

Week 4 NFL player props, every gameWashington Commanders season simulation and futures pricesIndianapolis Colts season simulation and futures pricesWeek 3 resultsEvery NFL futures price on the Futures SimulatorHow the simulator works

Other week 4 games

Pittsburgh Steelers at Cleveland Browns player propsArizona Cardinals at New York Giants player propsDallas Cowboys at Houston Texans player propsGreen Bay Packers at Tampa Bay Buccaneers player propsJacksonville Jaguars at Cincinnati Bengals player propsLos Angeles Rams at Philadelphia Eagles player props

Also from DataPitch

Futures SimulatorLock a result, re-run the season, and every price re-reads.Pregame PicksToday's fixtures, every player market we price, re-priced to your own numbers.In-Play AlertsCustomised in-play alerts on football player props: pick a player's shots, shots on target, fouls or cards, change the numbers, and the card lands in your Telegram while the match is on, free to use and priced when we hold live odds.GuidesPlain-word explainers on futures, player props, in-play alerts and the scenario tool.
Live Drive AlertsThe NFL watched live, with alerts on the markets we price in play.Upcoming