← Props Picker, this week's games
at

Indianapolis Colts at Kansas City Chiefs

Week 2 · Sun Sep 20, 8:20 PM ET · Market line KC -6 · total 46.5

How our calls did

Final: Indianapolis Colts 30, Kansas City Chiefs 33

Called before kickoff: 1. Won 1.

Each called row carries the same stamp in its market below. The green or red down a row's side is still our read against the price before kickoff, not how it ended. Prices taken Sun 20 Sept, 13:30 UK.

Every market we price

28 rows on 4 markets, best first: tap a market to open it, tap a player for his numbers, the price behind his and what our read rests on.

Receiving yards10
Noah Gray TE · KC 12+ receiving yards-112consensus market price

Noah GrayTE · KCReceiving yards

How it ended: Lost, 0 yds. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 47% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -6pp

Under 11.5: -112consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receiving yards
average 16.1, median 10
The line
11.5

His last 5, receiving yards

5v DEN2026 week 1
30v LV2025 week 18
2v DEN2025 week 17
0v TEN2025 week 16
14v HOU2025 week 14
Rashee Rice WR · KC 52+ receiving yards-112consensus market price

Rashee RiceWR · KCReceiving yards

How it ended: Won, 83 yds. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 44% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -9pp

Under 51.5: -112consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receiving yards
average 52.6, median 46
The line
51.5

His last 5, receiving yards

19v DEN2026 week 1
51v LAC2025 week 15
34v HOU2025 week 14
92v DAL2025 week 13
141v IND2025 week 12
More players (8)
Jonathan Taylor RB · IND 17+ receiving yards-113consensus market price

Jonathan TaylorRB · INDReceiving yards

How it ended: Won, 40 yds. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 43% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -10pp

Under 16.5: -115consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receiving yards
average 18.9, median 14
The line
16.5

His last 5, receiving yards

23v BAL2026 week 1
13v HOU2025 week 18
14v JAX2025 week 17
33v SF2025 week 16
14v SEA2025 week 15
Keenan Allen WR · IND 30+ receiving yards-116consensus market price

Keenan AllenWR · INDReceiving yards

How it ended: Lost, 5 yds. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 44% · Market 54%

Against this price: Gap -10pp

Under 29.5: -114consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer. His other lines below are the same simulated read of his game, cut at the thresholds the market quotes.

Our simulated receiving yards
average 31.3, median 26
The line
29.5

His last 5, receiving yards

32v BAL2026 week 1
25v NE2025 week 19
36v DEN2025 week 18
17v HOU2025 week 17
44v DAL2025 week 16

His other lines in this market

33+ receiving yardsDataPitch 40% · Market 53%-111book price at this line
Alec Pierce WR · IND 45+ receiving yards-114consensus market price

Alec PierceWR · INDReceiving yards

How it ended: Lost, 11 yds. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 43% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -10pp

Under 44.5: -114consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receiving yards
average 46.2, median 37
The line
44.5

His last 5, receiving yards

61v BAL2026 week 1
132v HOU2025 week 18
0v JAX2025 week 17
86v SF2025 week 16
16v SEA2025 week 15
Travis Kelce TE · KC 43+ receiving yards-114consensus market price

Travis KelceTE · KCReceiving yards

How it ended: Won, 101 yds. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 40% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -13pp

Under 42.5: -114consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receiving yards
average 40.9, median 35
The line
42.5

His last 5, receiving yards

71v DEN2026 week 1
12v LV2025 week 18
36v DEN2025 week 17
6v TEN2025 week 16
70v LAC2025 week 15
Kenneth Walker RB · KC 21+ receiving yards-115consensus market price

Kenneth WalkerRB · KCReceiving yards

How it ended: Won, 61 yds. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 34% · Market 54%

Against this price: Gap -20pp

Under 20.5: -112consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receiving yards
average 18.8, median 12
The line
20.5

His last 5, receiving yards

18v DEN2026 week 1
26v NE2025 week 22
49v LA2025 week 21
29v SF2025 week 20
36v SF2025 week 18
Tyler Warren TE · IND 43+ receiving yards-112consensus market price

Tyler WarrenTE · INDReceiving yards

How it ended: Lost, 21 yds. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 32% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -21pp

Under 42.5: -110consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receiving yards
average 34.8, median 29
The line
42.5

His last 5, receiving yards

13v BAL2026 week 1
26v HOU2025 week 18
43v JAX2025 week 17
30v SF2025 week 16
19v SEA2025 week 15
Xavier Worthy WR · KC 38+ receiving yards-113consensus market price

Xavier WorthyWR · KCReceiving yards

How it ended: Lost, 25 yds. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 31% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -22pp

Under 37.5: -110consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receiving yards
average 29.9, median 23
The line
37.5

His last 5, receiving yards

18v DEN2026 week 1
0v DEN2025 week 17
41v TEN2025 week 16
35v LAC2025 week 15
55v HOU2025 week 14
Josh Downs WR · IND 41+ receiving yards-118consensus market price

Josh DownsWR · INDReceiving yards

How it ended: Won, 72 yds. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 27% · Market 54%

Against this price: Gap -27pp

Under 40.5: -110consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receiving yards
average 29.5, median 24
The line
40.5

His last 5, receiving yards

37v BAL2026 week 1
61v HOU2025 week 18
34v JAX2025 week 17
65v SF2025 week 16
13v SEA2025 week 15
Receptions10
Noah Gray TE · KC 2+ receptions+145consensus market price

Noah GrayTE · KCReceptions

How it ended: Lost, 0 receptions. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 44% · Market 41%

Against this price: Gap +3pp

Under 1.5: -198consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receptions
average 1.7, median 1
The line
1.5

His last 5, receptions

1v DEN2026 week 1
3v LV2025 week 18
1v DEN2025 week 17
0v TEN2025 week 16
1v HOU2025 week 14
Rashee Rice WR · KC 5+ receptions-139consensus market price

Rashee RiceWR · KCReceptions

How it ended: Lost, 4 receptions. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 52% · Market 58%

Against this price: Gap -6pp

Under 4.5: +105consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receptions
average 5, median 5
The line
4.5

His last 5, receptions

2v DEN2026 week 1
7v LAC2025 week 15
4v HOU2025 week 14
8v DAL2025 week 13
8v IND2025 week 12
More players (8)
Travis Kelce TE · KC 4+ receptions-150consensus market price

Travis KelceTE · KCReceptions

How it ended: Won, 9 receptions. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 49% · Market 60%

Against this price: Gap -11pp

Under 3.5: +115consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receptions
average 3.8, median 3
The line
3.5

His last 5, receptions

3v DEN2026 week 1
3v LV2025 week 18
5v DEN2025 week 17
1v TEN2025 week 16
7v LAC2025 week 15
Jonathan Taylor RB · IND 3+ receptions-125consensus market price

Jonathan TaylorRB · INDReceptions

How it ended: Won, 4 receptions. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 38% · Market 56%

Against this price: Gap -18pp

Under 2.5: -104consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receptions
average 2.3, median 2
The line
2.5

His last 5, receptions

3v BAL2026 week 1
2v HOU2025 week 18
3v JAX2025 week 17
3v SF2025 week 16
3v SEA2025 week 15
Alec Pierce WR · IND 3+ receptions-162consensus market price

Alec PierceWR · INDReceptions

How it ended: Lost, 1 reception. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 42% · Market 62%

Against this price: Gap -20pp

Under 2.5: +121consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receptions
average 2.5, median 2
The line
2.5

His last 5, receptions

4v BAL2026 week 1
4v HOU2025 week 18
0v JAX2025 week 17
4v SF2025 week 16
1v SEA2025 week 15
Josh Downs WR · IND 5+ receptions+125consensus market price

Josh DownsWR · INDReceptions

How it ended: Won, 7 receptions. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 24% · Market 44%

Against this price: Gap -20pp

Under 4.5: -170consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receptions
average 3.1, median 3
The line
4.5

His last 5, receptions

2v BAL2026 week 1
4v HOU2025 week 18
2v JAX2025 week 17
5v SF2025 week 16
3v SEA2025 week 15
Kenneth Walker RB · KC 4+ receptions+130consensus market price

Kenneth WalkerRB · KCReceptions

How it ended: Won, 6 receptions. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 18% · Market 44%

Against this price: Gap -26pp

Under 3.5: -170consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receptions
average 2, median 1
The line
3.5

His last 5, receptions

3v DEN2026 week 1
2v NE2025 week 22
4v LA2025 week 21
3v SF2025 week 20
4v SF2025 week 18
Keenan Allen WR · IND 4+ receptions-125consensus market price

Keenan AllenWR · INDReceptions

How it ended: Lost, 1 reception. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 30% · Market 56%

Against this price: Gap -26pp

Under 3.5: -102consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receptions
average 2.7, median 2
The line
3.5

His last 5, receptions

6v BAL2026 week 1
3v NE2025 week 19
7v DEN2025 week 18
1v HOU2025 week 17
5v DAL2025 week 16
Xavier Worthy WR · KC 4+ receptions+105consensus market price

Xavier WorthyWR · KCReceptions

How it ended: Won, 5 receptions. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 22% · Market 49%

Against this price: Gap -27pp

Under 3.5: -138consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receptions
average 2.2, median 2
The line
3.5

His last 5, receptions

3v DEN2026 week 1
0v DEN2025 week 17
2v TEN2025 week 16
2v LAC2025 week 15
3v HOU2025 week 14
Tyler Warren TE · IND 5+ receptions-135consensus market price

Tyler WarrenTE · INDReceptions

How it ended: Won, 6 receptions. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 27% · Market 57%

Against this price: Gap -30pp

Under 4.5: +100consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated receptions
average 3.4, median 3
The line
4.5

His last 5, receptions

3v BAL2026 week 1
5v HOU2025 week 18
5v JAX2025 week 17
3v SF2025 week 16
3v SEA2025 week 15
Rushing yards6
Jonathan Taylor RB · IND 84+ rushing yards-113consensus market price

Jonathan TaylorRB · INDRushing yards

How it ended: Won, 92 yds. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 42% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -11pp

Under 83.5: -114consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated rushing yards
average 81, median 76
The line
83.5

His last 5, rushing yards

98v BAL2026 week 1
26v HOU2025 week 18
70v JAX2025 week 17
46v SF2025 week 16
87v SEA2025 week 15
Daniel Jones QB · IND 9+ rushing yards-115consensus market price

Daniel JonesQB · INDRushing yards

How it ended: Won, 10 yds. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 40% · Market 54%

Against this price: Gap -14pp

Under 8.5: -110consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer. His other lines below are the same simulated read of his game, cut at the thresholds the market quotes.

Our simulated rushing yards
average 11.4, median 5
The line
8.5

His last 5, rushing yards

4v BAL2026 week 1
4v JAX2025 week 14
1v HOU2025 week 13
16v KC2025 week 12
53v ATL2025 week 10

His other lines in this market

25+ rushing yardsDataPitch 15% · Market 24%+320book price at this line
More players (4)
Patrick Mahomes QB · KC 18+ rushing yards-113consensus market price

Patrick MahomesQB · KCRushing yards

How it ended: Lost, 17 yds. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 14% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -39pp

Under 17.5: -111consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated rushing yards
average 7.2, median 1
The line
17.5

His last 5, rushing yards

23v DEN2026 week 1
15v LAC2025 week 15
59v HOU2025 week 14
30v DAL2025 week 13
30v IND2025 week 12
Xavier Worthy WR · KC 10+ rushing yards+100consensus market price

Xavier WorthyWR · KCRushing yards

How it ended: Lost, 0 yds. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 8% · Market 50%

Against this price: Gap -42pp

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated rushing yards
average 2.3, median 0
The line
9.5

His last 5, rushing yards

0v DEN2026 week 1
1v DEN2025 week 17
0v TEN2025 week 16
0v LAC2025 week 15
0v HOU2025 week 14
Rashee Rice WR · KC 10+ rushing yards+100consensus market price

Rashee RiceWR · KCRushing yards

How it ended: Lost, 0 yds. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 6% · Market 50%

Against this price: Gap -44pp

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated rushing yards
average 1.9, median 0
The line
9.5

His last 5, rushing yards

0v DEN2026 week 1
0v LAC2025 week 15
0v HOU2025 week 14
2v DAL2025 week 13
0v IND2025 week 12
Kenneth Walker RB · KC 82+ rushing yards-114consensus market price

Kenneth WalkerRB · KCRushing yards

How it ended: Won, 117 yds. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 4% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap -49pp

Under 81.5: -111consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated rushing yards
average 24.3, median 17
The line
81.5

His last 5, rushing yards

173v DEN2026 week 1
135v NE2025 week 22
62v LA2025 week 21
116v SF2025 week 20
97v SF2025 week 18
Passing yards12
Patrick Mahomes QB · KC 222+ passing yardsWon382 yds-111consensus market price

Patrick MahomesQB · KCPassing yards

How it ended: Won, 382 yds. Called before kickoff, so it is in this game's count.

DataPitch 83% · Market 53%

Against this price: Gap +30pp

Under 221.5: -112consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated passing yards
average 296, median 291
The line
221.5

His last 5, passing yards

172v DEN2026 week 1
168v LAC2025 week 15
148v HOU2025 week 14
243v DAL2025 week 13
348v IND2025 week 12
Daniel Jones QB · IND 219+ passing yards-110consensus market price

Daniel JonesQB · INDPassing yards

How it ended: Lost, 210 yds. Not called before kickoff, so it is not in this game's count.

DataPitch 37% · Market 52%

Against this price: Gap -15pp

Under 218.5: -113consensus market price

Our structural read: how the game should flow, his role in it and the matchup. It has not yet been graded against results at real market prices, so treat it as our view of the player, not a priced offer.

Our simulated passing yards
average 202.7, median 197
The line
218.5

His last 5, passing yards

149v BAL2026 week 1
60v JAX2025 week 14
195v HOU2025 week 13
181v KC2025 week 12
196v ATL2025 week 10

Every price is a captured market quote in American odds, labelled as such; our percentage and the gap to the market's sit behind the row's tap. A row's colour is our number against the price: green means we rate the row's own selection well above what the price says, red means the price rates it more than we do, white means the two are close. A row's last five counts his last five games in this market, most recent first, regular season and playoffs.

Around this game

Week 2 NFL player props, every gameKansas City Chiefs season simulation and futures pricesIndianapolis Colts season simulation and futures pricesWeek 1 resultsEvery NFL futures price on the Futures SimulatorHow the simulator works

Also from DataPitch

Futures SimulatorLock a result, re-run the season, and every price re-reads.Pregame PicksToday's fixtures, every player market we price, re-priced to your own numbers.In-Play AlertsCustomised in-play alerts on football player props: pick a player's shots, shots on target, fouls or cards, change the numbers, and the card lands in your Telegram while the match is on, priced when we hold live odds.GuidesPlain-word explainers on futures, player props, in-play alerts and the scenario tool.
Live Drive AlertsThe NFL watched live, with alerts on the markets we price in play.Upcoming

Free on Telegram

Live player alerts, about 20 seconds behind the pitch

Shots, fouls and bookings as they happen, plus the daily match cards. Join the channel, it is free.